Brooklyn isn’t just a borough—it’s a flavor-packed playground for anyone who loves pizza. From classic New York-style slices to inventive pies that push the boundaries, Brooklyn’s pizza scene is legendary. Whether you’re a lifelong local or a first-time visitor, this guide will help you navigate the borough’s top pizzerias, hidden gems, and everything in between.
Let’s dive into the ultimate foodie’s guide to Brooklyn’s best pizza spots, where every bite tells a story.
Why Brooklyn Is the Pizza Capital of the World
Brooklyn’s pizza history runs deep. Generations of Italian immigrants brought their recipes and traditions, blending them with New York’s energy and creativity. Today, Brooklyn’s pizza shops range from old-school institutions to modern, experimental kitchens. The result? A diverse, delicious pizza landscape that attracts foodies from around the globe.
The Classics: Iconic Brooklyn Pizzerias You Can’t Miss
Di Fara Pizza
Ask any pizza enthusiast about Brooklyn’s best, and Di Fara will top the list. Opened in 1965, this Midwood staple is famous for its hand-crafted pies, fresh basil, and a crust that’s both crispy and chewy. Watching Dom DeMarco, the legendary founder, craft each pizza is a rite of passage for any pizza lover.
L&B Spumoni Gardens
For a true Brooklyn experience, make your way to L&B Spumoni Gardens in Gravesend. Their Sicilian square slices are legendary—pillowy dough, sweet tomato sauce, and a generous layer of mozzarella. Don’t forget to finish your meal with a scoop of their classic spumoni.
Grimaldi’s
Nestled under the Brooklyn Bridge, Grimaldi’s is a must-visit for coal-fired pizza fans. The smoky flavor, thin crust, and fresh toppings have made it a tourist favorite and a local go-to for decades. Arrive early to beat the crowds—this spot is always buzzing.
Neighborhood Favorites: Where Locals Go for a Slice
Lucali
Tucked away in Carroll Gardens, Lucali is the definition of a neighborhood gem. Mark Iacono’s candlelit pizzeria draws pizza pilgrims with its thin, blistered crust and simple, high-quality ingredients. Bring your own bottle of wine and settle in for a memorable meal.
Paulie Gee’s
In Greenpoint, Paulie Gee’s is a haven for creative pizza lovers. Their wood-fired pies feature inventive toppings like hot honey, vegan cheeses, and locally sourced produce. The cozy, rustic atmosphere makes it perfect for date night or a casual dinner with friends.
Totonno’s
Coney Island’s Totonno’s has been serving up classic pies since 1924. Their secret? A coal oven, fresh mozzarella, and a commitment to tradition. It’s a slice of history you can taste in every bite.
Hidden Gems: Off-the-Beaten-Path Pizza Spots
Emily
Clinton Hill’s Emily is a modern favorite, known for its unique “Emmy” style pies and the famous Burger (yes, it’s worth the hype). Their pizzas feature a crisp, airy crust and bold flavor combinations—try the “Colony” with pepperoni and honey for something unforgettable.
Best Pizza
Don’t let the humble name fool you—Best Pizza in Williamsburg delivers on its promise. White-tiled walls, a wood-fired oven, and a menu that balances classic and creative make this a must-try for pizza purists and adventurers alike.
Speedy Romeo
In Bed-Stuy, Speedy Romeo brings St. Louis-style flair to Brooklyn. Their pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven, topped with everything from smoked mozzarella to roasted Brussels sprouts. It’s a fresh take on tradition that keeps locals coming back.
What Makes Brooklyn Pizza So Special?
Brooklyn pizza stands out for its balance of tradition and innovation. The dough is often fermented for extra flavor, the sauce is vibrant and tangy, and the cheese stretches just right. Many pizzerias use coal or wood-fired ovens, giving the crust that signature char and crunch.
But it’s not just about technique—it’s about passion. Brooklyn pizza makers pour their hearts into every pie, whether they’re following a family recipe or inventing something new.
Tips for the Ultimate Brooklyn Pizza Crawl
- Start Early: Popular spots like Di Fara and Grimaldi’s fill up fast. Arrive before peak hours to avoid long waits.
- Bring Cash: Some classic pizzerias are cash-only, so come prepared.
- Try Different Styles: From Sicilian squares to Neapolitan rounds, sample a variety of crusts and toppings.
- Share with Friends: Pizza is best enjoyed together. Order a few pies and taste as many flavors as you can.
- Save Room for Dessert: Many spots offer Italian sweets like cannoli, gelato, or spumoni—don’t miss out!
Beyond the Slice: Brooklyn’s Pizza Culture
Pizza in Brooklyn isn’t just food—it’s a way of life. From late-night slices after a concert to family gatherings around a big pie, pizza brings people together. Many pizzerias support local farms, host community events, and even offer pizza-making classes. It’s a culture built on sharing, creativity, and a love for good food.
Frequently Asked Questions About Brooklyn Pizza
What’s the difference between New York-style and Brooklyn-style pizza?
While both feature a thin, foldable crust, Brooklyn-style is often a bit crispier and can be cooked in coal or wood-fired ovens for extra flavor.
Can I find vegan or gluten-free pizza in Brooklyn?
Absolutely! Many modern pizzerias, like Paulie Gee’s and Emily, offer vegan cheeses, gluten-free crusts, and creative plant-based toppings.
Do I need a reservation at popular Brooklyn pizzerias?
Some spots, like Lucali, don’t take reservations—be prepared to wait, especially on weekends. Others, like Paulie Gee’s, may offer limited reservations online.
Planning Your Brooklyn Pizza Adventure
Ready to embark on your own Brooklyn pizza tour? Map out your route, gather your foodie friends, and bring your appetite. Whether you stick to the classics or venture off the beaten path, you’re sure to discover slices that will have you coming back for more.
Conclusion: Brooklyn Pizza Awaits
Brooklyn’s best pizza spots offer more than just a meal—they deliver an experience. From the sizzle of a fresh pie to the laughter of friends sharing a table, every visit is a memory in the making. So grab a slice, savor the flavors, and join the ranks of pizza lovers who know that Brooklyn is the place to be.
Ready to taste the best pizza in Brooklyn? Share this guide with your fellow foodies, plan your pizza crawl, and let us know your favorite slice in the comments below!
